Principle #8: Stop supporting prosecution in cases against people who manage their own care or offer community-based care, fail to seek care, refuse care, or fail to disclose their private medical information
SUBSECTIONS
Why This Principle?
Invitations to Action
Reflection Questions
Reflect
Research
Practice
Imagine
Further Resources for Reflection and Discussion
Why This Principle?
Care outside of formal medical systems has existed in all cultures since time immemorial and will continue to exist outside of formal systems of care. Self-managed care and community care, including Indigenous, traditional, spiritual, and plant-based healing practices, are important parts of how people and communities survive, stay in connection, and practice cultural healing traditions, and will continue to exist outside of formal systems of care.
Traditional healing modalities and medicines outside of colonial Western medicine have historically been criminalized on Turtle Island. Many health care providers are taught that Western care modalities are superior and to look down on traditional and community-managed care instead of seeing them as part of a larger system that can work cooperatively to keep people well.
People seek reproductive, gender-affirming, or other forms of care outside of medical systems, or self-medicate using criminalized and controlled substances, for many reasons, including because:
they don't have access to insurance or care inside those systems;
they have limited choices;
they don’t trust health care systems or have experienced trauma within those systems;
they are exercising their self-determination and autonomy to choose the forms of care that feel best to them.
Migrant, trans, queer, disabled, and unhoused people are increasingly being criminalized and denied access to care under current conditions, leading more people to self-manage care.
Simultaneously, self-managed care is increasingly under attack under current and evolving conditions of consolidating authoritarianism, particularly when it comes to reproductive and gender-affirming care, use of criminalized and controlled substances, and supporting access to criminalized care.
Criminalizing, reporting, stigmatizing, or delegitimizing people who provide, support, or receive care outside the system doesn’t address the underlying factors leading people to self-manage care, drives them further from seeking care within the formal health care system, and limits their options when self-managing care, including monitoring and health education.
Even if we don’t agree with all forms of self-managed care or are concerned about the risks, criminalization won’t stop people from engaging in self-managed care and is likely to increase associated risks and harms, including surveillance, policing, prosecution, and punishment.
Stigmatization of self-managed care and traditional healing practices drives them further underground instead of addressing risks and concerns and providing information that can lead to better care in any form.
Creating open channels of communication about self-managed care without criminalization (or documentation, testing, or screening that could lead to criminalization) and providing people with information and support they need to self-manage care is essential to ensuring that everyone seeking care receives the best possible quality of care.
Invitations to Action
Treat provision of care as a partnership — rather than a relationship in which “legitimate” providers and systems exercise power over people seeking care — by supporting individual dignity and self-determination and providing resources and information that support well-being as defined by individuals.
Never report patients you suspect or know are engaged in self-managed care. Address their current medical needs, find out if there are barriers to access that can be addressed, and provide them with as much medical information and support as possible around the care they are seeking. Connect patients with legal resources to support them in learning more about the nuances of the law and making informed decisions around self-managed care.
Do not participate in or support prosecution of self-managed care and be careful not to create evidence that can be used in such cases (see Principle 2 on information gathering and documentation practices).
Work to change laws around self-managed care and make systems-based care safer, more affordable, and more accessible.
Deepen your knowledge of and increase access to information and resources around self-managed care, and resist the consolidation of knowledge and power by providers who work within systems that gate-keep information.
Reflection Questions
-
Have you ever managed your own health care outside of health care systems?
How? Why?
What benefits did you experience?
What challenges did you face?
How might your health care providers have better supported you?
Reflect on the reasons that someone might choose to manage their own care, seek community-based care, refuse care, or withhold medical information in your community.
Is it safe, accessible, or comfortable for all community members to access care in formal medical care systems? Why or why not?
Which kinds of self-managed care are normalized (think: supplements, exercise regimens, home remedies) and which are criminalized (think: self-administered abortion medication, hormone replacement therapy, or even gender transition without medical interventions)? What differences do you notice between normalized and criminalized self-managed care? How are systems of power at play?
How are different groups of people treated differently around self-managed care?
How might criminalization of self-managed care push folks further away from mainstream health systems rather than building trust and connection? What risks and consequences are associated with pushing people further from mainstream health systems?
What forms of care are increasingly being criminalized or made cost-prohibitive, pushing people to self-manage or seek care outside of formal health care systems, refuse care, or withhold medical information?
How might unauthorized use of controlled substances be understood as a form of self-managed care in the absence of other options?
How might medical risks associated with some forms of self-managed care be reduced without criminalization?
Why and how can you imagine people might use controlled or criminalized substances as a form of self-managed care?
How might you support them in navigating these realities as a health care provider?
Check out these curated stories about disability justice on the Timeline of the Medical Industrial Complex by the Healing Histories Project.
Reflect on medicine's history of abuse and experimentation, and the communities that have been targeted.
Why might some communities, such as disabled, intersex, neurodivergent, migrant, Indigenous, Black, or criminalized people, distrust medical professionals and choose to manage their own care? What is needed to help improve trust and catalyze a stronger sense of partnership between people seeking care and medical professionals?
What harm, risks, pain, stigma, shaming, or (re)traumatization accompany different types of treatment?
Read "Healing Ourselves as Indigenous People" about how traditional healing modalities outside of colonial Western medicine were criminalized across Turtle Island.
How were you taught to view self-managed care or traditional healing modalities and medicines outside of colonial Western medicine?
How can you begin to shift your own or others' perceptions toward de-stigmatizing self-managed care in service of our patients’ self-determination and bodily autonomy?
-
What forms of self-managed care are criminalized in your community, state, county, or discipline (e.g., midwifery care, home birth, lactation, self-managed abortion and miscarriage, hormone therapy, drug use, harm reduction)?
How do people engaged in self-managed care come to the attention of authorities? What role do health care workers play?
What are the consequences of criminalization of self-managed care?
Which groups of people have been or are being criminalized in your community for self-managing care? For refusing care? What about the people who support them?
How are health care workers implicated?
What kinds of support could you offer people to manage self-care or community-based care safely?
What efforts are underway to decriminalize self-managed care in your community, state, county, or discipline?
How can you advance or support policies that resist criminalization of reproductive autonomy?
Are you required to report self-managed care? Is this a policy or law, or a norm that isn't required? How else can you address self-managed care besides reporting, criminalizing, or condemning it?
-
How can you start to normalize conversations about self-managed care in your practice, health care setting, or profession?
Review these clinical recommendations from the Society of Family Planning regarding self-managed abortions and how to provide non-judgmental, compassionate care.
How might you incorporate these recommendations into your practice? How might you invite your colleagues and co-workers to do the same?
If your patients have legal questions about self-managed abortion care specifically, or abortion laws generally, they can contact the Repro Legal Helpline. Reach out to If/When/How for resources or legal trainings for your health care setting.
Share the M+A (Miscarriage and Abortion) Hotline with folks who might need more clinical support.
Use free resources from Abortion On Our Own Terms to facilitate a workshop on self-managed abortion with your colleagues or pod.
Educate yourself on self-managed and community-provided gender-affirming care for trans people.
Learn more about DIY trans health care in the DIY HRT Directory, read this guide from Lighthouse Learning Collective and Alyssa Rodriguez Center for Gender Justice about navigating access to gender-affirming hormone therapy, and read this article about silicone fillers. But keep in mind that trans people may use various other types of self-managed or community-provided care as well.
Think about how you would respond to a person who comes in for care whose labs indicate that they are likely on hormones a provider did not prescribe. Talk with your co-workers about what you can do to make your health care setting a place where they would not face criminalization, punishment, or judgment for accessing care in the way they can, and instead receive supportive information and resources — including resources to share with their communities on how they can access support for self-managed care.
Familiarize yourself with harm reduction-based resources and efforts to decriminalize drug use in your community (see discussion questions and resources for Principle 6).
-
What might it look like for everyone to access the care they need in the way they want to access it, where they want to access it?
Paint a picture with words or images of a community where care is available in all forms at all times to all people, in ways that honor agency, self-determination, consent, and the right to accessible and high quality care.
What/who is needed to make this vision real?
What is one step you can take today toward that vision?
Read the Physicians for a National Health Program’s proposal for Medicare for all.
How does self-managed care appear in the plan?
How could the plan be expanded to address barriers to care that lead people to self-manage care?
How could the plan be expanded to ensure coverage and support for self-managed care?
Further Resources for Reflection and Discussion
If you or your group get stuck or want to go deeper on any of the questions above, check out the invitations and readings below!
"Constructing the Modern American Midwife: White Supremacy and White Feminism Collide," about the history of formal vs. informal care, professionalization, and licensing through the lens of U.S. midwifery.
Underground networks of care, like the Jane Collective in Chicago in the 1960s.
The history of DIY trans care in "Doctors Who?" by Jules Gill-Petersen.
This interview with Ceyenne Doroshow on the NYC Trans Oral History Project.
If/When/How’s report Self-Care, Criminalized: The Criminalization of Self-Managed Abortion from 2000 to 2020.
Abortion Decriminalization is Part of the Larger Struggle Against Policing and Criminalization from Interrupting Criminalization.
We Must Fight in Solidarity with Trans Youth from Interrupting Criminalization.
Decolonize the Future, excerpted from Movement Generation’s Course Correction series, by Tré Vasquez
What will be possible because we remembered?
Even in a world rapidly working to disconnect us from being human
We remembered
That even if someday we can no longer grow what we need from the soil
That We are still the soil
That we are made from the earth, water and air
And so we protect them with our lives the way we protect each other
We are seed savers
Story tellers
Living libraries
Foreseers of the future and portals to the past
The students of pollinators
Organizers
Campesinxs
Yerberas
Sacred clowns
Brown & down computer hackers
Song keepers
We are lovers
Doctors
Birth workers birthing new worlds
Transcending smoking ashes unfurled
Messengers air dropping seeds of resistance
On a world collapsing into herself
WE are a prayer of Remembrance
We learn to move like underground rivers
Hiding to preserve our force and medicine
Emerging as springs to sustain Life
Reminding the people to only use what they need
& So I’m reminding you to Never forget the ones that are coming
To reciprocate now, while there is time
Make yourselves into waterways
Trusting where you are going…