Principle #7: End mandated reporting
SUBSECTIONS
Why This Principle?
Invitations to Action
Reflection Questions
Reflect
Research
Practice
Imagine
Further Readings for Reflection and Discussion
Why This Principle?
Mandated or mandatory reporting is a legal requirement that certain people report what they perceive to be situations of child or elder abuse or neglect, domestic violence, and suicidality to the family police ("child welfare services" or "child protection services") and other authorities.
Health care workers and staff who are mandated reporters are essentially deputized by the state to police and surveil their patients and call the on state to intervene under certain conditions.
Mandatory reporting is a highly discretionary practice. Whether, when, and who to report is strongly shaped by forces of power and privilege. Who we deem to be "dangerous," "deviant," "neglectful," and "a risk to themselves and/or others” — and thus warranting state intervention — is heavily rooted in racism, classism, cisheteropatriarchy, ableism, and other systems of oppression.
Mandated reporting is not an evidence-based practice, and has not been proven to improve situations of harm. In fact, it often makes things worse.
Mandatory reporting undermines patient and provider autonomy, self-determination, and trust, damages therapeutic relationships, and forces people in need of care into under-resourced systems that often place them at greater risk of harm, which, in turn, undermines patient health. Defaulting to making a report even when required by law — often called the "better safe than sorry"/"when in doubt report" approach — compounds these harms, while also directly violating laws protecting patient confidentiality and informed consent.
People who experience harm deserve to seek support and services at their own pace without fear of involvement in the criminal punishment or family policing systems. Having to constantly calculate how much to share, with whom, and how to seek support under the constant threat of family separation or incarceration takes a huge psychic, spiritual, and emotional toll.
People who may be struggling to meet their own or their family's needs deserve support. Mandatory reporting and punishment systems, like the family policing system and criminal legal system, don't provide that.
Invitations to Action
Offer people resources to prevent, interrupt, exit, transform, and heal from difficult and harmful circumstances that don’t also place them at risk of criminalization, family separation, and further harm.
Communicate your legal role as a mandatory reporter to people seeking care, as well as the kinds of information that might trigger a mandated reporting requirement, how the information would be documented in a record, who else on the care team may have access to it, the limited options and resources available if a report is made, and the potential consequences.
Read your state and local laws and regulations as well as your institution's internal policies regarding mandatory reporting and get clear on what they do or don’t require.
Discuss mandated reporting laws, regulations, and policies with trusted friends and colleagues. Mandatory reporting is highly discretionary, and what many people think they "must" report is over-broad, and overstates what the law, regulation, or policy require.
Question and shift policies and laws around mandatory reporting.
Reflection Questions
-
What do you believe is the purpose of mandatory reporting? What have you been taught in school or in workplace trainings?
Have you ever made a report or witnessed a health care worker make a report to the family policing system (otherwise known as "child welfare" or "child protective services") or the criminal punishment system?
Did it improve the situation? From whose perspective (e.g., the person experiencing harm, the health care worker, state actors, community members)?
Did it make it worse in any way?
What are the harms of a “when in doubt, report” approach?
If you don't know what happened following the report, why is that?
Mandated reporting can make providers feel comfortable with looking away based on the assumption that another person or system will address the situation.
If you have not made a report, what do you think would happen if you did?
Listen to "Mandatory Reporting is Over Policing," from the Mandatory Reporting Is Not Neutral Storytelling Project.
What are some of the impacts of mandatory reporting on parents and caregivers?
How do mandatory reporting requirements sit in tension with best practices around informed consent, patient autonomy and dignity, patient- and family-centered care, confidentiality, and trust?
Can you think of any other supports you might offer instead of reporting someone? What would you do if you had a patient who needed support or was experiencing harm and mandatory reporting were not an option?
What do you think would happen if the family policing system disappeared? Would children experience less safety or more?
Read "How the Pandemic Became an Unplanned Experiment in Abolishing the Child Welfare System." What do you think about the findings in this article?
-
Are you a mandated reporter? What are you actually required to report in your state as a mandated reporter?
Review the Balancing Risk Assessment Tool (BRAT) for mandated reporters and look up common consequences and convictions for failing to report under the mandated reporting laws in your state.
Check out this resource from If/When/How on concrete ways to mitigate the harms of a report.
Look up the numbers of mandated reports in the United States over time from 1985 to 2019 (most recent available data) in the "Visualizing Mandatory Reporting Research Graphic" on Mandatory Reporting is Not Neutral’s website.
What trends do you notice over time?
What is the racial breakdown of people who are the subject of reports?
What is the percentage of unsubstantiated reports over time? What does this tell you about what is happening?
Learn more about the disproportionate targeting of parents by the family policing system.
Read the National Domestic Violence Hotline’s report on the experiences of survivors of domestic violence with law enforcement and the criminal punishment system, and the report on LGBTQ survivors experiences, There’s No One I Can Trust.
-
If you are a mandated reporter:
Do you always let people seeking care from you know that you are a mandated reporter?
How might you share this information with them, and the consequences, while maintaining their trust? Practice with a colleague until you feel that you have struck the right balance.
How might you share this information with them in an ongoing way (e.g., when soliciting information that may trigger a report, how might you remind or flag for your patient that their response could trigger a report, allowing the patient, in that moment to determine what feels safest to care)?
How might you balance laws around patient confidentiality and informed consent with mandated reporting requirements?
It can be upsetting when you think people seeking care, especially children, elders, and survivors, are experiencing abuse or neglect. Check out the PAUSE framework to support you in moments when you feel urgency or activation in taking time to slow down, consider next steps, and extend support.
Practice factoring in the risk of harm (short and long-term) that flows from a report (e.g., investigation, family separation, foster system, displacement) into your analysis on whether to report.
Pick one of the essays from the Reclaiming Safety series from the upEND Movement— what could it look like to implement some of the best practices described in the essays?
Practice going through the risk assessment questions on page 15 of the Balancing Risk Assessment Tool (BRAT) with a friend or colleague, and discuss how you would navigate the realities of mandated reporting.
Check out the "Reports Are Not Support: Mandated Reporting Harm Reduction" webinar with Shannon Perez-Darby and other resources at Mandatory Reporting is Not Neutral.
Start a conversation with other staff or providers you trust about mandated reporting — why you report, what you are actually required to report, why reporting may lead to more harm, what other options are available, and how to live into your ethical commitment to do no harm.
Don't work through this alone! Check out the Network to Advance Abolition in Social Work's Abolitionist Peer Supervision Guide, and find a group of providers to support each other as we work towards reducing the harms of mandated reporting in our practice.
Practice supporting people seeking care to use resources like:
The Bay Area Transformative Justice Collective (BATJC)'s Pod-Mapping Toolkit;
Safety Planning and Intimate Partner Violence Toolkit from Community Justice Exchange, Survived and Punished, and Interrupting Criminalization;
You Matter: An Illustrated Guide for Young People Beyond Mandatory Reporting from Mandatory Reporting is Not Neutral.
-
What if instead of paying a foster family over $76,000/year, we gave it to families facing separation based on unmet needs for food, housing, transportation, childcare, respite care, and other forms of support?
Check out the upEND Movement’s Dream, Create, Liberate: A Future Without Family Policing — what’s one approach to harm that the stories and poetry unlocked for you? How might you move toward making it a reality?
Read “Baby Che’,” a short story on pages 46–55 about organizing community safety and care against the forces of the child welfare system.
Further Resources for Reflection and Discussion
If you or your group get stuck or want to go deeper on any of the questions above, check out the invitations and readings below!
Learn about the history of the family policing system:
This interview with Dorothy Roberts and Lisa Sangoi on the history of the family policing system/"child welfare” system.
This zine discussing the impacts of mandated reporting in schools.
The history of the family policing system, including the colonial history of forced family separation and residential schools, and the impacts of the family policing system on Indigenous families today.
"Mandated Supporting," a video from Just Making A Change for Families (JMACforFamilies) and Social Workers Against Mandates (SWAM).
Transgender Law Center’s video on "Mandatory Reporting, Abolition, and Trans and Disability Justice."
Resources from Movement for Family Power.
Criminalizing Survival from Survived and Punished.
Police Responses to Domestic Violence in this fact sheet by Interrupting Criminalization.
What About The Rapists? A zine by Mariame Kaba and Eva Nagao at Interrupting Criminalization.
How to End Family Policing: From Outrage to Action, edited by Erin Miles Cloud, Erica R. Meiners, Shannon Perez-Darby, and C. Hope Tolliver.
“Toward the Abolition of the Foster System” by Erin Miles Cloud.
ProPublica and NBC News investigations into the child welfare system.
"Abolish Family Policing, Too" by Dorothy Roberts.
Resources from upEND Movement about the movement to end family policing.
“Mandatory Reporting is Over Policing,” Mandatory Reporting is Not Neutral Storytelling Project
“... Today, I live in constant fear of policing from anyone on a power trip… My life is filled with shame, alienation, hurt, and anger… Based on my experience of mandatory reporting, I believe: mandatory reporting disrupts the lives of children; mandatory reporting destroys marriages and families; mandatory reporting is overpolicing; mandatory reporting is invasive and abusive… mandatory reporting forever destroys the reputation of good people; mandatory reporting is not a solution. Other options exist. Better interventions exist! Let's use them. Pointing fingers and shaming families in the public square needs to stop. Mandatory reporting is not the answer to frontline protection of children and families. The rights and dignity of families matter..."
There's No One I Can Trust: The Impact of Mandatory Reporting on the Help-Seeking and Well-Being of Domestic Violence Survivors, National LGBTQ Domestic Violence Capacity Building Learning Center
“The majority...said that the report made the situation worse or had no impact. 50% of participants who have been reported said it made the situation much worse.”
Jacqueline Peoples, “Baby Che’"
"CPS is using a form of brutality to separate families, and we are going to be responsible for one another. We are our brother's keeper.”