Principle #12: Stop collaborating with the criminal punishment system to violate people in custody, including through performing cavity searches at the request of police or prison officials; evaluating competency to stand trial; experimenting on and sterilizing people who are incarcerated; facilitating torture; or administering the death penalty
SUBSECTIONS
Why This Principle?
Invitations to Action
Reflection Questions
Reflect
Research
Practice
Imagine
Further Resources for Reflection and Discussion
Why This Principle?
Health care providers collaborate with police, court, jail, prison, immigration, family policing, civil commitment, military, and intelligence agencies to facilitate surveillance, coerced medical interventions, creation of evidence, torture (including “enhanced interrogation”), and execution of the death penalty. Providers also participate in experimentation and forced sterilization of people who are incarcerated. And, care workers are involved in evaluations to render people competent to stand trial, be subject to civil commitment, or be put to death.
Invitations to Action
We call on health care providers to speak out and refuse to participate in any collaboration with systems of policing, punishment, incarceration, and deportation.
-
Have you or your colleagues ever been asked questions or asked to perform an exam in service of law enforcement? Or asked to conduct a test that was later used as evidence against someone in need of care?
What were the circumstances and how did you respond?
How do you wish you had responded?
What kinds of things do criminal punishment, family policing, or border enforcement systems do that would not be possible without the collaboration of health care providers?
How might health care providers organize to collectively refuse to perform these tasks?
When health care workers participate in systems of punishment, how are they violating the primary principle of “do no harm?”
Read "The Rise of Medical Fascism" by Eric Reinhart — in what ways are you ready to be part of the Hippocratic underground?
Where do you feel resistant or reluctant and why? What could support or embolden you to do more?
-
How are health care providers in your profession, health care setting, or community participating in the criminal punishment, family policing, or immigration systems?
Is there a medical forensic unit attached to your local prosecutor’s office?
Who is conducting drug tests for your local court, probation, or parole offices?
Who do local police, sheriffs, jail, prison, or immigration officials go to when they want someone to conduct a cavity search or to assign someone a gender?
Where does the local jail, prison, or ICE detention center bring incarcerated people for medical interventions?
Who is conducting psychological assessments as part of competency proceedings? Civil commitment proceedings?
Who is administering the death penalty in your state?
Are there professional standards, regulations, or ethics guidance that you can rely on or cite when refusing to participate in such activities? For example, read the APHA's statement on addressing the harms of the carceral system and the AMA Code of Medical Ethics’ section on capital punishment.
Are health care providers already organizing against these practices? Who are the people, groups, organizations, and allies you can build with to push back against such practices? Make a list and convene a gathering to develop a plan for refusal to participate in such harms.
Learn more about the long history of health care workers' complicity in state violence.
"American Psychological Association Bolstered C.I.A. Torture Program"
"From Nuremberg to Guantánamo, Medical Professionals Enabled Torture"
Read about the experiences of survivors of California’s forced sterilizations.
How does it feel to learn about health care workers' participation in harm?
What does it inspire you to do?
-
As you move through your day, notice how you, the people you work with, and people in your profession or discipline are being asked and tasked to collaborate with violations and coercion of people subject to any form of state surveillance, custody, or control.
Think of and try out one small way you could refuse — and invite others to do the same.
Read Refusing Carceral Collaborations: Ideas for Health Care Workers.
“Standing Up to Cops in the ER: Part I and II” on pages 3–4
How might you and your colleagues practice responding to such requests so that you are better prepared to refuse them when they occur?
“No to Force Feeding” on page 7
How might you speak out and invite health care providers to refuse to participate in the force-feeding of migrants and prisoners on hunger strikes who are calling attention to atrocious conditions of incarceration?
Read about the force-feeding of hunger strikers in ICE detention and Physicians for Human Rights’ fact sheet on Hunger Strikes and the Practice of Force-Feeding.
“ICE Whistleblower” on page 6
What did Dawn Wooten’s actions make possible?
What whistleblower protections exist in your institution and state?
What might you need to blow the whistle on? How can you ensure that you have the support you need to do so?
“Refusing to Perform a Cavity Search” on page 2
How might Dr. Ash have intervened to prevent the harm he refused to participate in from happening elsewhere?
Read about how doctors were charged after refusing to perform a body cavity search, and read this piece on emergency physicians refusing to comply with body cavity search warrants.
Read this 2019 Minnesota Supreme Court decision disavowing an unlawful cavity search that occurred in collaboration between the Minneapolis Police Department and Hennepin County Medical Center doctors in Minneapolis.
According to the court, were the hospital's actions legal?
How could the muddying of boundaries between health care provider and police officer negatively affect patient care?
Why do you think all the fellow doctors, residents, nurses, techs, and other emergency department staff were afraid to speak up and stop this offense?
-
What would happen if health care providers refused to participate in executions? If they refused to participate in abortion prosecutions? If they refused to examine or drug test people against their will? If they refused to participate in forced psychiatric incarceration? How might the world look different if providers refused to participate in the harm of criminalization?
Further Resources for Reflection and Discussion
If you or your group get stuck or want to go deeper on any of the questions above, check out the invitations and readings below!
"A Warrant to Search Your Vagina” by Andrea J. Ritchie.
The impact of a nonconsensual genital exam on an incarcerated trans man.
"More immigrant women say they were abused by ICE gynecologist."
"US moving pregnant immigrant girls to Texas to avoid providing abortions, critics say."
"No Más Bebés," a film that follows a group of immigrant mothers in 1970s Los Angeles who sue the U.S. government in response to coerced sterilizations.
Black Feminist Voices' roundtable discussion on histories of sterilization and resistance.
"It's Time to End Forced Sterilization — And Write a New Reproductive Equity Story by and For Disabled People" from the National Women’s Law Center.
"Surviving Surveillance, Catering to America," a short film about the surveillance, entrapment, and imprisonment of a Muslim family in the wake of 9/11.
Death Penalty Information Center’s year-end reports.
Aurora Levins, “V’ahavta”
"...Embroider them on your garments, tattoo them on your shoulders, teach them to your children, your neighbors, your enemies, recite them in your sleep, here in the cruel shadow of empire: Another world is possible.”