Principle #11: Stop providing and/or sanctioning substandard/violative care for people who are in custody or incarcerated in jails, prisons, detention centers, residential centers, group homes, and state facilities
SUBSECTIONS
Why This Principle?
Invitations to Action
Reflection Questions
Reflect
Research
Practice
Imagine
Further Resources for Reflection and Discussion
Why This Principle?
Treatment in jails, prisons, detention, residential, congregate, and psychiatric facilities is often absent, substandard, as well as coercive, invasive, and violent. Practices include (but are not limited to): shackling pregnant people during labor and delivery; use of restraints; non-consensual forced feeding; inadequate access to healthy food, clean drinking water, temperature regulation, basic health care and treatment; forced sterilization; coercive treatment by health care staff; and neglect and disregard of health care needs, illness, or injuries. Health care providers are complicit in medical violence and neglect through participation in substandard and coercive care in spaces of incarceration.
Health care workers are also implicated in substandard care and medical neglect for incarcerated people by failing to ensure the highest standards of care and consider the conditions people are living in when incarcerated people are brought into their health care settings, and by returning people to spaces where they will be subject to medical violence and neglect.
Locked psychiatric wards, nursing facilities, “sheltered” workshops, and mandated and coercive psychiatric and medical interventions and facilities reproduce the same carceral logics as prisons and jails — denying patients autonomy and control over their own medical decisions, schedules, and choices about how they care for themselves. These spaces often also provide substandard medical care and support to the people within them. It is important for health care workers to identify when carceral logics are showing up in spaces that claim to offer care, and to take action to improve conditions and interrupt controlling and coercive policies and practices.
Health care workers can and must be powerful advocates on behalf of incarcerated people.
Invitations to Action
If you work in carceral facilities, call out and refuse to participate in abusive or coercive practices in health care.
Advocate for transfers to accredited, accessible, and quality health care facilities and release.
Question and challenge narratives that incarcerated people receive “better” care on the inside than on the outside — ask yourself and others:
if that is in fact the case;
if so, why that might be;
what standards that sets for care;
how underlying issues and causes of criminalization and barriers to access to care would be better addressed by providing high quality universally accessible care in communities. Even when medical care is available in carceral facilities, we must reflect on our long-term goals — consider whether it is possible to truly be well in a cage. It is our responsibility as care providers to deconstruct all conditions that contribute to adverse health outcomes — including those resulting from incarceration and family separation.
If you work in a traditional health care setting, challenge the culture of deference to enforcement officials, and protect patient rights to access the highest quality of care, privacy, and informed consent.
Support the efforts of incarcerated people to demand care and freedom, and join campaigns to shrink the size, scope, legitimacy, and power of carceral institutions, including as potential spaces of “care” (i.e., “mental health” jails).
Don't collaborate with the criminal punishment system to coerce “care” through forced psychiatric treatment, mandated drug treatment, and court-imposed “counseling” programs.
Join decarceration campaigns to close jails, prisons, and detention facilities and stop coerced psychiatric incarceration and drug treatment.
Reflection Questions
-
Watch and listen to “Beyond This Place” by Clint Smith — how do you think about people who are incarcerated?
Does it depend on what kinds of facility they are incarcerated in? Why?
Does it depend on the crime that the individual committed?
Do other factors influence how you think about them?
What do you know about the availability and quality of care received by people incarcerated in jails, prisons, or detention centers in your community?
What about residential facilities, group homes, or locked psychiatric wards?
Have you or has anyone you know worked in any of these settings? What stories have you heard from folks working in these facilities or from incarcerated individuals?
What actions have you or your colleagues taken to raise awareness about substandard care, or what strategies would you imagine trying to intervene in solidarity with incarcerated people or people in police or ICE custody?
Read an interview with Mumia Abu-Jamal's "movement" doctor, Ricardo Alvarez, on his health crisis while incarcerated and how "The Only Treatment Is Freedom."
How can we balance the need to ensure that people who are incarcerated receive the care they need and deserve, and the reality that incarceration itself is harmful and an inherent barrier to care, that there is no such thing as care in a cage?
How do we avoid advocacy, organizing, and research efforts that pour money and resources into "improving" carceral institutions to provide better quality care instead of building non-carceral alternatives?
Read "Beware the Healthier Cage" by Mark Spencer to learn more about the pitfalls of carceral humanism.
If you are working in or in collaboration with health care provision in a carceral facility:
What are your duties to the people you are caring for vs. those of the institution or corporation you are working for?
How are you documenting harms, medical neglect, and abuse you might be witnessing and participating in?
How might you maximize your impact on securing medical release? On resourcing transitions out of the facility?
What settings (such as drug treatment programs, nursing facilities, group homes, sheltered workshops, locked psychiatric facilities) might be framed as spaces of care but actually serve as spaces of surveillance, incarceration, punishment, and neglect?
How can health care providers help ensure that people inside such spaces are receiving care and exercising the maximum degree of autonomy and self-determination, and that they are supported to live in community free from restraint?
-
Based on reports from people inside, what are the conditions in your local jail, prison(s), and/or immigration detention facility?
Which providers, health care facilities, and/or corporations are charged with providing care for people in:
police custody;
ICE custody;
the local jail;
prisons and detention centers;
residential facilities (group homes, nursing facilities, etc.) in your area?
Do you know anyone who works for/with them?
What is their experience?
How might you engage them?
What standards of care for incarcerated people exist in your state (i.e., Can incarcerated pregnant people be shackled during labor and delivery? Are d/Deaf and Hard of Hearing People, HIV-affected, and disabled people provided with interpretation, medications accommodations, and support?)
How are they enforced? What role do health care providers play in enforcing them?
How can we support people incarcerated to advocate for their rights to access care? For example, check out Know Your Reproductive Rights In Prison from Unapologetically HERS and the California Coalition for Women Prisoners.
What are your health care settings' policies with respect to treatment of people who are incarcerated/in police/ ICE custody, in terms of shackles, police/prison guard presence during treatment/in treatment areas, confidentiality, etc.? What are the common practices? Why are health care facilities so deferential towards carceral authority?
How might you change this policy or these practices to improve care for incarcerated people/people in custody?
What legislative or policy efforts are currently underway to address failure to provide care to incarcerated people in your community or state? How might you support them?
Listen to this conversation between Kelly Hayes and formerly incarcerated organizer Monica Cosby about people in prison organizing for survival. How are criminalized and incarcerated people organizing to demand care — and freedom as care — in your community or state?
How have health care providers supported these struggles? How could they?
Learn about Hardel Sherrell's tragic death in a rural Minnesota jail in 2018.
What role do private correctional care companies play in adverse outcomes? Is there a conflict of interest between providing care for incarcerated individuals and making a profit?
How did this case ultimately get leaked to the public?
How are serious medical diagnoses missed in incarcerated individuals when they arrive at emergency departments?
-
Listen to or read The Right to Dignity: Securing Compassionate Release for Incarcerated People about how a physician in Georgia utilizes compassionate release as an approach to care for incarcerated patients.
How might you support people in demanding freedom as a medical necessity? Check out the work of Chicago Medical Legal Collaborative and Medical Justice Alliance.
Check out Stop Criminalization Of Our Patients (SCOOP)'s curriculum on the carceral system and its impacts on health and work through the modules with fellow students or your co-workers.
Check out Is it a Rule or is it a Law?, a story about a resident physician pushing back against cruel hospital rules that impact care for incarcerated patients, and this story about a physician fighting for her incarcerated patient's right to an abortion.
How might you incorporate some of the interventions the storytellers used in your practices, profession, or health care setting? How might you encourage others to do the same?
Given what you know about the lack of care, adequate food, water, climate control, cleanliness, space and other conditions inside jails, prisons, and detention centers, how might you ensure that people brought into your health care setting in custody are not discharged to places where their conditions are likely to worsen and they will not receive adequate follow up?
Watch "Fire Through Dry Grass."
How might you shift your practices and those of your colleagues and health care setting in order to better support agency, autonomy, and self-determination of disabled people and people with unmet mental health or medical needs?
Read about the fight to stop an LA County “mental health jail” in which health care workers played a prominent role.
-
Imagine yourself in a future where the very idea of policing and punishment in a health care setting would be seen as ludicrous. What would it feel like to receive and give care in this future world?
Read Franny Choi’s poem the "Field Trip to the Museum of Human History."
Check out "The Prison Cell" by Mahmoud Darwish.
Read Benji Hart's poem "Layleen's Bill (With Revisions)."
Further Resources for Reflection and Discussion
If you or your group get stuck or want to go deeper on any of the questions above, check out the invitations and readings below!
The complete absence of care in ICE detention facilities like Fort Bliss, and how they stopped paying contractors who were providing necessary medical care.
Invisible Institutions podcast about invisibilized harms of the institutional system for people labelled with intellectual and developmental disabilities in Canada.
These firsthand accounts by children detained inside the immigrant family detention center in Dilley, Texas.
Detention Health Preparedness Guide about understanding one’s right to medical care.
"We've Entered the Gaslighting Phase of COVID in Prisons" by Victoria Law.
HEARD’s documentary "Deaf in Prison."
"The Perils of Private Prison Health Care," a documentary by CBS News.
This article about the violence of institutionalization and state neglect of disabled people.
Campaigns by Californians United for a Responsible Budget (CURB), The National Council for Incarcerated and Formerly Incarcerated Women and Girls, and California Coalition for Women Prisoners, and the Decarceration During COVID-19 Messaging Toolkit by Community Justice Exchange and Public Health Awakened.
Leveraging Governmental Public Health Tools to Address the Harms of the Criminal Legal System, a toolkit by Health in Partnership (formerly Human Impact Partners) and Critical Resistance.
“Carceral humanism” and the oxymoronic “feminist jails,” and how they are contradictions in terms.
#SurvivedAndPunished: Survivor Defense as Abolitionist Praxis, a toolkit by Love and Protect and Survived and Punished. Join campaigns to get people free. Learn about freedom teams and create your own.
“Prison as a Tool for Reproductive Oppression: Cross-Movement Strategies for Gender Justice” by Gabriel Arkles.
If They Build It: Organizing Lessons & Strategies Against Carceral Infrastructure by Community Justice Exchange. Check out pages 48-49 on jails as care providers and 66-70 for health impacts of alternatives/reforms/replacements to carceral infrastructure.
Clint Smith, “Beyond This Place,” Future of StoryTelling 2015
“I immediately recognized how deeply socialized I've been to think of these men [in prison] in a very specific sort of way.”
Layleen’s Bill (With Revisions) by Benji Hart
for Layleen Cubilette-Polanco Xtravaganza
The New York City Council will pass a package of legislation,
expanding services for transgender, gender-nonconforming,
non-binary, and intersex inmates will turn out its pockets,
never sign another ransom note
All officers with trans inmates in their custody will undergo
a competency training will have their badge numbers
etched off with diamond-tipped acrylics, aquamarine
New beds will be added to the transgender housing unit
beds of wildflowers will erupt from lots that were not
vacant, just holding their breath
Counselors will be made available to all trans inmates we
are each our sister’s counsel
The Board of Correction will convene a task force will
be tasked with something useful, like beekeeping, or collecting
rainwater
Sex workers will have their cases diverted to Human Sex
Tracking Intervention Court will spray paint the words
“we are the intervention” on the courthouse rubble
The Rikers Island compound will be replaced by a series of
smaller, borough-based facilities will slip into the rising
Atlantic, the ribs of our dead prepared to cage it
Trans elders will be held in solitary confinement for their
own safety will have their charcoal locs retwisted in
chosen hands
This legislation will take effect in the summer of 2020
we have never asked permission to sing