Principle #3: End screening and testing without explicit and informed consent
SUBSECTIONS
Why This Principle
Invitations to Action
Reflection Questions
Reflect
Research
Practice
Imagine
Further Resources for Reflection and Discussion
Why This Principle?
Full, explicit, informed consent is a core tenet of ethical care. A commitment to doing no harm requires a commitment to honoring people’s self-determination, dignity, privacy, and consent.
Refusal to consent to testing can also lead to involvement of and violence by security or police. In practice, patients often feel pressured to consent or cannot truly refuse testing without experiencing other additional negative consequences, even potentially being denied access to care.
Health care workers can intentionally or inadvertently become tools of surveillance, policing, criminalization, and punishment through non-consensual drug, alcohol, STI, and hormonal testing and screening practices, especially when results are used as evidence in criminal and civil proceedings, or to exclude people from public spaces or public life. For instance, people run the risk of family separation and getting kicked out of school, employment, and benefit programs on the basis of drug screenings, denied the opportunity to participate in sports due to gender and sex testing, and being subjected to involuntary testing in the context of reproductive and gender-affirming care.
Experiencing surveillance, stigma, or trauma in health care settings can discourage people from seeking care.
Individuals in police, prison, or ICE custody, involved in the family policing system, or held in carceral psychiatric systems should have a right to make their own medical decisions with full informed consent.
Involuntary testing is rooted and results in a lack of trust between providers and people seeking care and perpetuates stigma and prejudice. Health care workers are often taught to see people seeking care as "unreliable reporters" at best and liars and manipulators at worst. The belief that testing is the only way to verify that patients are telling the truth and warrants overriding consent, is dangerous and unfortunately widespread in health care.
Invitations to Action
Ensure all medical screenings, testing, and procedures are performed with full, explicit, informed consent, and that "consent" means the same thing to all those ordering and performing tests, including the lab technicians, nurses, and medical assistants. Ensure everyone providing care is trained in consent practices and equipped to answer questions about testing.
Refuse to screen or test people without their full, explicit, informed consent, unless they are in critical condition and unable to communicate, and testing is necessary to inform medical decisions.
Form a working group to challenge and change harmful screening or testing policies at your institution or program.
Work to the extent possible to support the rights of people in state custody and control or in contact with the criminal punishment, immigration, or family policing systems to exercise full informed consent around their medical care and prevent medical decisions from being made or overridden by agents of the state.
Support campaigns that ensure informed consent, like the Informed Consent NY Coalition, and reach out and invite fellow medical providers and birth workers to join you or to start a similar initiative in your community!
Reflection Questions
-
Have you witnessed or experienced patient drug, alcohol, hormone, pregnancy, psych, or abuse screening without explicit, full informed consent and right of refusal?
Have you witnessed or experienced testing of a patient's bodily fluids without explicit, full informed consent and right of refusal?
Who experienced testing or screening without consent? What populations are most likely to experience this?
How was the decision made to proceed without full informed consent? What laws or policies are used as justification, whether criminal or civil laws, institutional policies, or a discretionary decision by a health care provider?
Was the person screened or tested in some form of state custody or control? Or were they seeking care independently?
If consent was obtained, what made you feel like it was less than full or explicit?
What kinds of pressures or conditions was the person consenting under?
What information was missing that is necessary for the consent to be informed and voluntary?
Did they know whether they could refuse testing and what the impact of refusing would be?
What was the impact on the person seeking care? How did a lack of full informed consent affect the quality of care provided or the relationship of trust between the person seeking care and care providers? What were the consequences of the test or screen on the person's life (i.e., did it lead to a report or investigation)?
What was the impact of the screening or testing on the course of care? Would the course of treatment have been different without the screening or test result?
-
Under what circumstances does your jurisdiction permit or require non-consensual drug or alcohol screening?
After a motor vehicle accident?
When a person is in state custody or control?
When mandated by a court or as a condition of pre-trial release, probation, or parole?
When a person is pregnant or parenting?
For children?
Do you work in a context where health care providers are required to perform drug or alcohol tests on behalf of the state or report instances of positive drug tests?
To whom? How?
How does this align with your professional rules of conduct regarding informed consent and doing no harm?
Your institutional policies?
Your personal sense of ethics and responsibility?
Can you refuse to run tests when asked by the state?
Learn more about a nurse’s refusal to take a patient’s blood without consent when ordered to by police.
How does your state handle suspected or confirmed drug or alcohol use during pregnancy and postpartum?
Check out the Legislative Analysis and Public Policy Association’s Substance Use During Pregnancy and Child Abuse or Neglect: Summary of State Laws and If/When/How's resource on Prenatal Drug Exposure: CAPTA Reporting Requirements for Medical Professionals.
How does your health care setting handle newborn positive drug tests? What is the impact of non-consensual drug testing of children?
How are drug and alcohol tests used by the state as evidence of "criminality," "child maltreatment," "incompetence," "good moral character," etc., to build criminal and civil cases (e.g., family policing/"child welfare,” immigration, involuntary commitment, etc.) targeting vulnerable patients/clients?
How many drug treatment programs and harm reduction centers in your community offer care to pregnant people and parents? Do they allow the parent to bring their children to live with them in the program, or offer pregnant and parenting clients with opioid use disorders access to life-saving medication treatments such as methadone or buprenorphine?
What other kinds of non-consensual medical screening or testing are health care workers asked or required to perform by police, probation, parole, prison, and immigration authorities in your area?
Is it required for a medical treatment or procedure or is it being conducted for some other reason (perhaps to gather evidence for a legal case)?
-
What does full, informed, and explicit consent mean to you? What could it look like given the realities of your practice and health care setting?
Grab a co-worker and practice asking for consent and offering information before conducting drug, alcohol, pregnancy or hormonal testing or screening with clients or patients in your work under typical conditions in your setting — what improvements can you make realistically?
How might you clearly explain why this test or screen is being conducted, what it will be used for, and any consequences or impacts to the patient within time and other constraints of your daily practice?
How could you ensure that there is consent for additional/follow-up screening or testing once samples have been collected?
Review the approaches suggested in the National Harm Reduction Coalition’s Pregnancy and Substance Use: A Harm Reduction Toolkit.
How are these approaches aligned with your workplace’s current practices and how do they diverge from them?
Pick one strategy you can practice where you are.
Read "Standing Up to Cops in the ER" in Refusing Carceral Collaborations: Ideas for Health Care Workers.
How might you practice enforcing patients' rights to informed consent when someone is in state custody or control?
-
Listen to or read this zine from Beyond Do No Harm's Storytelling Media Project from a nurse midwife on helping a patient navigate family court and Child Protective Services to keep their child and avoid any further family separation.
How can we center the autonomy of our patients and refuse surveillance and policing of their bodies and families?
Imagine a world where consent, respect, self-determination, and autonomy are centered, and structural relations of power are not abused.
What does it feel like? What is required of each of us (i.e., person seeking consent, person giving consent, community at large) to make it real?
What are the barriers in the way of such a world (e.g., stigma, policy, fear)? How can we be part of knocking them down?
Further Resources for Reflection and Discussion
If you or your group get stuck or want to go deeper on any of the questions above, check out the invitations and readings below!
"Battling an Unjust System: How the War on Drugs Stole My Daughter" by Dinah Ortiz.
Putting an End to Drug Testing by Drug Policy Alliance.
Clinical Drug Testing of Pregnant People and Newborns, and Confronting Pregnancy Criminalization by Pregnancy Justice,
“Medical and Public Health Group Statements Opposing Prosecution and Punishment of Pregnant People" by Pregnancy Justice.
"Reclaiming Safety for Children Whose Parents Use Substances" by Kassandra Frederique, Dinah Ortiz, and Mark Z.
How the Foster System Has Become Ground Zero for the U.S. Drug War by Lisa Sangoi for Movement for Family Power, NYU Family Defense Clinic, and the Drug Policy Alliance.
Movement for Family Power’s report Drug Tests Are Not Parenting Tests.
"The Violent Policing of Black Motherhood" by Andrea J. Ritchie.
"How Often Does Child Welfare Call Police in Your State for Positive Drug Tests at Birth?” from The Marshall Project,
"Moms of Black Babies More Likely to Be Flagged to Police Over Alleged Pregnancy Drug Use" from The Marshall Project.
Self-Management of Care from Physicians for Reproductive Health.
“Policing Motherhood” in Invisible No More: Police Violence Against Black Women and Women of Color by Andrea J. Ritchie.
Histories of non-consensual testing and screening, such as the Tuskegee Syphilis Study, through Healing Histories Project's Stories of Care and Control: A Timeline of the Medical Industrial Complex.