Principle #1: End police and ICE presence in hospitals and in or near health care facilities
SUBSECTIONS
Why This Principle?
Invitations to Action
Reflection Questions
Reflect
Research
Practice
Imagine
Further Resources for Reflection and Discussion
Why This Principle?
The presence, surveillance, and violence of armed agents of the state in spaces where people are seeking and providing care is antithetical to the concept of care itself — which is why this is the first principle for providers committed to honoring their commitment to "do no harm." The violences of policing, criminalization, punishment, incarceration, family separation, detention, deportation, and denial of care are — by definition — forms of harm.
Armed police, ICE, security, and other enforcement agents in health care spaces place patients, staff, and community members at greater risk of physical and fatal violence and harm, including through use of physical and chemical restraints. There have been numerous deaths, injuries, violent arrests, and instances of denial of care in hospitals at the hands of police.
Anti-Blackness, racism, ableism, misogyny, homophobia, and transphobia all deeply inform policing practices such as securing compliance through violence and use of restraints, including for non-normative behaviors associated with disability.
Police and ICE presence in health care settings deters people from seeking care, particularly for criminalized populations such as Black and Indigenous people, migrants, disabled people, drug users, trans and queer people, people in the sex trades, HIV-affected people, pregnant people, and abortion seekers, as well as people who have pending warrants, charges, or removal orders, or are otherwise at risk of arrest, and people on probation or parole.
Police and private security do not effectively address the safety needs and concerns of patients and health care workers and often jeopardize the safety of everyone in a health care facility.
Invitations to Action
Declare your health care facility a sanctuary space from ICE, police, and policing — and organize with your colleagues, comrades, and allies to make this a reality! Support and join organizers working to divest from campus and hospital policing and invest in care.
Eliminate hospital policies and practices that criminalize patient and visitor behavior and identification, drug use, refusal of treatment, disability, and other issues that commonly lead to calls for security or police.
Develop measures designed to address structural issues such as understaffing, overcrowding, denial of access to care, lack of cultural competency, and coercive medical interventions that contribute to violence in health care settings.
Build community-based safety strategies such as unarmed safety and de-escalation teams, peer networks, mutual aid groups, and social services. Check out the Building Coordinated Crisis Response resource from Interrupting Criminalization.
Coordinate with groups working on sexual assault prevention who understand that the presence of cops in health care settings is harmful, does not prevent violence or keep people safe, and deters survivors from seeking care.
Document injuries and conditions caused by state agents and medical neglect in custodial settings, including their causes and sequelae, in detail in medical records.
Reflection Questions
-
What does police presence look like in your health care setting? ICE presence? Private or institutional security? Probation or parole officers?
How do policing agents enter your health care setting? Use BDNH's Timeline of Hospital Criminalization to map potential points of entry and interaction such as providing security, bringing people into the facility, coming into a facility to interview or arrest someone, being stationed inside a health care facility to gather evidence of abuse, sexual assault, or domestic violence, or responding to calls from health care workers or faculty staff.
How do different law enforcement agencies interact with people seeking or in need of care in each of these contexts? People offering care? Visitors, family, and community members? Each other?
Which individuals and communities do their activities focus on?
How does racial, gender, or professional identity, immigration status, or disability inform experiences of police and/or ICE presence in health care settings, as a patient, provider, or staff member?
How are the practices of different agencies similar or different?
How does their presence create barriers to care? How does it escalate already charged situations?
-
How long have police, ICE, private security, or other enforcement agencies been present in hospitals and health care settings in your community?
How did they come to be there?
Watch BDNH’s two-part strategy session webinars on the history of policing in health care and efforts to remove police from health care settings.
What were the systems of oppression (think: anti-Blackness, ableism, patriarchy), historical conditions, and forces that led to this development?
How much does it cost to hire private security or cover the cost of police presence?
How else could those funds be used to increase staffing, hire patient navigators, and change conditions that contribute to workplace violence and poor patient care?
Research your health care institution's policies around ICE and police presence.
Is there a specific policy for patients brought in in ICE custody or for protective measures in the event of an ICE raid?
How is it different from policies governing police, sheriff, and jail, probation, parole, or prison staff presence?
Compare your institution's policy to California's Model Policy for Immigration Enforcement in the Healthcare Setting developed by health care workers organizing to get ICE out of health care.
-
Think through scenarios in which police and/or security are typically present or called (such as enforcement of hospital drug or visitation policies; profiling and control of patients deemed to be "aggressive," "non-compliant," or "drug seeking;" when a patient is sexually explicit, racist, transphobic or homophobic; or if a patient, family member, or visitor becomes agitated or assaults staff or destroys hospital property).
How are labels like "aggressive," "non-compliant," or "drug-seeking" produced and justified? Who are they disproportionately applied to? Under what conditions do they become justification for police involvement?
What could be done instead of calling the police? How could you practice a world rooted in care, not punishment? Who can you connect with to help you build this practice?
What knowledge, skills, and resources would you and/or others need to acquire or deepen to make this response a reality?
How could the situation have been prevented?
What structural factors (e.g., long wait times, under-staffing, inaccessible care spaces/environments, unclear procedures for triaging and prioritizing care, lack of patient navigators or support staff who can explain procedures and support people in crisis while they wait for care, lack of access to health care or quality, affordable culturally competent health care, harm reduction, and housing options in community, etc.) contribute to workplace violence and violations of hospital policies?
What could be done to mitigate or eliminate these structural conditions (e.g., changes to hospital policy, advocating for and creating community-based care, access to Medicaid/Medicare insurance and care coordination, harm reduction and housing programs, etc.)?
What would you do if ICE came into your institution, whether to take someone away or to bring in a person who had been harmed? Have you talked to your co-workers about what you would do? Practice using role play!
Decide what roles you would need and how they would be distributed, then practice them! Check out this Guide on Organizing to Keep ICE Out from Black Rose.
Read "Healthcare Workers Freed a Patient From ICE – You Can Do the Same" from Black Rose.
What steps were necessary for the workers to take before ICE arrived?
How could you start to build a network at your institution that is ready to respond to a patient being brought in by ICE? Reach out to trusted folks and have a conversation about what this might look like. How could this network be mobilized for patients brought in by local police or corrections officers?
How could you organize in your wider community to get ICE and police out of health care?
Listen to or watch a medical student's story about organizing to get cops out of care, and the story "On the Consequences of Policing Patient Behavior in the Hospital" about a physician challenging the policing of his patients.
Learn more about Healthcare Workers for Abolition in San Francisco (formerly DPH Must Divest).
-
Read the stories of Nicholas Burgos and Alan Pean. How do these articles make you feel? Can you imagine a different ending to these stories?
What would your health care settings look like if we treated every life as precious?
What would it look and feel like to receive and give care if this was true?
If criminalization is the antithesis of care and care is the antidote to violence, what does a liberatory approach to care require?
Further Resources for Reflection and Discussion
If you or your group get stuck or want to go deeper on any of the questions above, check out the invitations and readings below!
"Abolish ICE Means Abolish the Police" with Interrupting Criminalization co-founders Andrea J. Ritchie and Mariame Kaba.
This Trauma Code podcast interview with a health care provider in Minneapolis on how the culture of deference to law enforcement in health care settings paved the way for ICE in hospitals (40:30).
Midwife Asmara Gebre’s strike to protest the use of sheriffs for security at San Francisco General Hospital.
Health care workers organizing in Minneapolis to defend their patients from ICE, and health care workers in LA organizing to ensure implementation of a county-level policy around ICE in health care and protesting the health harms and violence caused by immigration raids, ICE detention, the Los Angeles County jail system, and complicit local hospitals.
Read about the public health crisis unfolding from ICE presence in our communities and hospitals deterring patients from necessary care.
CIR/SEIU Model Policy for Immigration Enforcement in the Healthcare Setting.
Physicians for Human Rights fact sheet on Establishing Sanctuary Hospitals: Protecting the Right to Access Health Care.
Resources for advocating for racialized and immigrant patients in the face of ICE:
Muslims for Just Futures' Community Defense Resource Hub;
Everyone Belongs Here’s provider resources;
National Immigration Law Center’s Health Care Providers and Immigration Enforcement: Know Your Rights, Know Your Patients' Rights.
"Institutions Often Treat Disability and Mental Health Not With Care But Violence," an interview with Liat Ben-Moshe, and this interview with Idil Abdillahi on the intersection of anti-Blackness and ableism.
"Policing the Emergency Room" in the Harvard Law Review.
Police in the Emergency Department: A Medical Provider Toolkit for Protecting Patient Privacy from Georgetown University Health Justice Alliance.
"Get Armed Police Out of Emergency Rooms" in Scientific American.
"Let's Take the Punishment Out of Healthcare" from White Coats for Black Lives.
Read about a survivor of police sexual violence who went to a hospital for care and to document what happened to her — but left because police presence at the hospital made her fearful — and whose identity was disclosed to police anyway.
Andrea J. Ritchie, in Unmasked: Impacts of Pandemic Policing, pages 5–6, COVID19 Policing Project
“They loved each other by looking for the cracks [sickness] crept through and closing them — they canceled rent and mortgages, they made sure everyone had quality, affordable housing, they paid everyone — everyone — what they needed to stay home, they made all healthcare free, they made tests available to anyone who wanted one —and mandated no one to take one. They told the police to stay away, stay home. They loved the people who had been caged by setting them free and welcoming them home to safe places and inviting them to dream a new life for themselves.
They loved the healthcare workers by giving them everything they needed to stay safe, enough equipment, ventilators, medication, humane schedules, healers for healers, care for their families and ways to come home to them without fearing that they were bringing death with them. They loved them like they were life itself and celebrated them with permanent living wages, protections, and sustaining working conditions.
They loved disabled people and gave thanks and gratitude for sharing all the ways they had learned to live together and apart, all the wisdom they had grown about how to care for themselves and each other, and all the brilliance of their beings. They loved them by prioritizing their care, and by refusing to deem anyone disposable.
…
They loved each other safe. They loved each other home. They loved each other free.”